Toledo’s Emmanuel McNeil-Warren Slides to Browns in Second Round of 2026 NFL Draft

Toledo safety Emmanuel McNeil-Warren slid into the second round of the 2026 NFL Draft despite early projections suggesting he could go in the first. The Cleveland Browns selected him in the back half of the second round, with sources indicating a lack of consensus on his first-round potential led to the drop. McNeil-Warren was ranked 62nd overall by Pro Football Prep with a B+ grade, but he ended up being the 58th overall player selected.

McNeil-Warren had a standout career at Toledo, where he recorded 118 tackles, seven interceptions, and two forced fumbles in his final season. His 6’1”, 215-pound frame and physical style of play drew interest from teams needing a hard-hitting safety. Prior to the draft, most NFL teams had him graded as a day-two prospect, though one team considered him a first-round option.

The Browns, who selected McNeil-Warren at No. 58 overall, have depth at safety with veterans Grant Delpit and Ronnie Hickman. McNeil-Warren will likely begin his NFL career as a rotational player, learning behind established starters. His development timeline could be accelerated if he shows early NFL readiness.

With the Browns looking to rebuild their defense, McNeil-Warren’s addition gives them a physical safety with upside. He will compete for playing time in training camp and could emerge as a starter by the end of his rookie season. The Browns’ decision to draft him reflects their need for talent at the position and their willingness to invest in young players.

McNeil-Warren’s draft journey reflects a broader trend in the 2026 class, where several players, including Jermod McCoy and Harold Perkins, also slid below expectations. As training camp approaches in August, all eyes will be on how quickly McNeil-Warren adapts to the NFL pace.