Omenihu Weighs In on Lamar vs. Josh: Allen Would Win Title with Ravens

Charles Omenihu believes Josh Allen has the tools to win a Super Bowl, if he can avoid costly mistakes. The former Kansas City Chiefs pass rusher, now with the Washington Commanders, made the claim on the "Speakeasy" podcast, arguing that while defenses have adapted to Lamar Jackson, they have yet to solve Allen’s unique skill set.

Omenihu played against both quarterbacks and offered a direct comparison. “With Lamar, honestly, you bring a five-man rush on him and collapse that pocket, he’s drifting backwards and, unfortunately, he might make a play that isn’t going to be the best play for the Ravens,” he said. “With Josh, he’s going to drift backwards, run around, and he’s so hard to tackle. He’s a large human being. Hard to get down. He can make every throw. Every throw from no matter where he’s at. His arm strength is unbelievable.”

The debate between Jackson and Allen has persisted despite both players falling short in the 2024 playoffs. Neither quarterback made the AFC Championship Game, and both struggled with turnovers in key moments. Jackson threw three interceptions in the Divisional Round against the Bengals, while Allen fumbled a critical snap in the snow against the Broncos.

Omenihu sees a clear difference in how defenses approach each quarterback. “The speed,” he said when asked what advantage Jackson holds. “If you do let him out, he’s gone. And he’s not going to fumble the ball. Josh is going to fumble the ball. That’s the thing about it. If Josh could just chill on the turnovers, don’t try to be Superman all the time, the Bills, I think, beat the Broncos.”

Omenihu also believes Allen’s potential is best realized with the Ravens. He cited the team’s offensive and defensive talent as a better fit for Allen’s style. “You’ve got Derrick Henry, you’ve got Zay Flowers, you’ve got Mark Andrews. You have a defense. You’ve got Roquan Smith, you’ve got Kyle Hamilton, you’ve got Marlon Humphrey. You’ve got some guys. You’ve got some pieces.”

Allen has thrown for 4,500+ yards in each of the past three seasons and has 97 touchdowns in that span. Jackson, meanwhile, has 86 touchdowns in the same period but has also rushed for 1,000+ yards in two of those years. Both have Pro Bowl seasons on their résumés, but neither has a playoff win to show for it.

Omenihu’s assessment adds to the ongoing conversation about how each quarterback can evolve. For Jackson, it may mean finding more weapons and consistency in the passing game. For Allen, it’s about reducing turnovers and trusting the process. The 2025 season will be a critical test for both.

The Ravens open the 2025 season on September 5 against the Pittsburgh Steelers. The Bills kick off their campaign the same week with a home game against the Miami Dolphins.